Volume 21, Issue 1
September 2026
An Open Letter from a Concerned Techno-Optimist
By: Simon Moon
A satirical sequel to “The Techno-Optimist Manifesto” by Marc Andreessen; Unattributed quotes are from this piece.
Dearest Luddites & philistines,
I speak for all of us visionaries when I say that I am concerned. Your ignorance and insolence are starting to get out of hand despite our best efforts. In the past, you ate out of our hand. Why, then, have you taken to eating on your own? It boggles our minds that more than the tiniest modicum of you believe that our masters of your minds are for your detriment. We have tried to cure you of this illness of dissent for many years. We warned you of the lies that infest your minds and plague your souls with the dark clouds of foresight. Misinformation is winning in the war we, the enlightened, wage against reality. Did we really say that your jobs would be preserved by technology? That inequality would not grow? That society would not be turned to ash? That your physical world and being would remain whole? You hold us to too high of a burden. You tell your own children the fable of Santa Claus, a lie, to make them believe in the necessity of good will and the generosity of a higher power. So, too, we spun our stories. Your jobs were a leprechaun; your society, the tooth fairy; your choice, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer. We had to help you take your medicine. Are we in the wrong? Should we be shamed for the help we give you? Why then do you not trust us?
Look at history and, tell us, have we not led you to prosperity, to comfort? “Our civilization is built on technology. Technology is the glory of human ambition and achievement, the spearhead of progress, and the realization of our potential.” When you desired immortality, we invented gunpowder. When your homes were in flames, we made asbestos. When the slums irked your conscience, we gave you gentrification. Just look at how many ways we have ended war! The plane, the machine gun, dynamite, mustard gas! And we finally found the answer in the atomic bomb; after all, what’s a little existential threat and intangible violence, when you can be safe from conventional warfare? Do you not prefer our thousand invisible bullets to one real one? You stand on the shoulders of us, the giants, and complain about the view. The gall! Only our kind hearts, not our wallets (believe me they are already plenty deep), prevent us from letting you fall to the cold, hard earth. Each generation is repulsed by technology, our dark magic, but slowly succumbs to it within the next half century or so. If we were so evil, if we meant harm, why would you keep coming back?
Perhaps, though, only the future motivates you; that undying pestilence of precaution has so taken some of you that I would be remiss to not consider such a possibility. Our jobs, our jobs, our jobs! Oh, if I had a penny for each time those nails grated against the chalkboard of my ears! If you are so prescient, then why can’t you see? Your work was already on the way out! Is it not for the better? For the last 200 years, you have argued with us about wages this, unions that, too dangerous this, work-life balance that. Now you are free! You complained every second that we employed you, so go! We wanted to relieve you of your misery, to give you comfort, to make you more pliable and now we unshackle you from this burden. The same with art! How miserable artists are! That pathetic, limp giant insect’s only word of any value was that “art for the artist is only suffering . . .” First, we tried to relieve you of that desire for art with Marinetti. Sadly, you little beasts did not take too kindly to that; if only we could remove the color from your eyes! But that was in the past. Look ahead. If we cannot free from you the desire for it, we have released you of the need to make it. The consumption of art was not what we sought to destroy, but that misery that leads to “great” art, that dissent and aberrance that comes with horrid foresight and thought. Now, a program, bereft of misery, can be your Van Gogh, Picasso, and Banksy. Now do you see? We have given you life without anything worth living for, humans without humanity. And now, with the digital world, we have given you realness without reality and existence without existentialism. Isn’t it better without consequence or reason?
We are the better Prometheus. We give you fire. When God cursed our Babel, we became the gods; we made God an atheist. We blacked the sun to spite its flames and cursed the ocean for its tides. We sterilize life and death all the same. Why can’t you just trust us after we have put the silver spoon in your mouth? You claim that you’ll wake up one day and the night will be dark from our light, the world black from our luminaries, and existence empty from the void we filled it with. And I say, so what? So what if the stars hide their fires? With the stars gone, the sky will be ours to hold. What right do you have to thwart us, to think us wrong? Who gave you the right to be unhappy? No one. “It’s time to be a techno-optimist.” “You owe it to the past and to the future.”
You are mine truly,
The Techno-Optimist